"This report describes changes in the offending outcomes observed for 79 young people who between October 2010 and December 2013 graduated from 11 Military-style Activity Camps (MACs) held at Te Puna Wai ō Tuhinapo youth justice residence in Christchurch. All of these young people had a post-MAC follow-up period of at least 12 months so their follow-up offending could be observed."
"The reoffending outcomes ...for MAC graduates appear very similar to those seen for all young people who have received SwR orders. However caution must be taken with such a comparison, as measuring the impact of the MAC relative to SwR would require a robust statistical approach such as a matched comparison analysis. This could usefully be undertaken in the future."
Another report looks at the recidivism rate for those who went through the Youth Court and received supervision orders:
"Records for a total of 552 young people who received a stand-alone Supervision (SUP) order between 1 October 2010 and 31 March 2013 were examined."
A final report looks at recidivism rate among those who went through a Family Group Conference process. The outcomes are slightly better but these are probably the less serious offenders.
Based on these graphs the Military style camps had the least success.
On a brighter note, according to the summary:
On a brighter note, according to the summary:
Offending by children aged 10-13 years has dropped in the last five years for both genders, across all ethnic groups and ages, across almost all offence types, and in all regions.
A falling youth crime rate is not unique to New Zealand, and the reasons for the fall are unclear and therefore subject to debate.
Much of the drop in offending by children in New Zealand has been because fewer children are becoming offenders in the first place – a very positive finding.
4 comments:
That's because we don't need military camps -- we need a real military solution to crime in the first place.
Northern Ireland, for example, has the lowest rate of drug abuse in the West. Guess why?
"Northern Ireland, for example, has the lowest rate of drug abuse in the West. Guess why?" says some Anonymous
https://r1016132.wordpress.com/2016/08/16/keep-it-illegal-for-all-i-care-ill-tell-you-what-though-youd-better-stay-away-from-copperhead-road/
Bring it on I say.
One kneecap for your first "offence", Jamie.
Like I said before Anonymous
Bring it
Post a Comment