Tuesday, July 03, 2012

CYF notifications for 2010/11

More from the MSD Statistical Report just released.

The next set of figures is interesting and quite misleading unless you read through the text carefully. Since 2007/08 the Police have been required to notify CYF whenever they attend a family violence incident where children are present. Up until 2010/11 the police referrals were combined in general notifications. Last year where they did not require further action they have been listed separately. So what the following chart actually shows is that notifications not requiring further action are increasing.


 table CY.1: Numbers of notifications received and requiring further action
Outcome of initial assessment of notifications received Number of notifications received1,2
2006/2007 2007/2008 2008/2009 2009/2010 2010/2011
Notifications requiring further action 43,845 40,739 49,224 55,494 57,949
Police family violence referrals3 - - - - 57,153
Notifications not requiring further action 28,082 48,722 61,573 69,427 35,645
Total notifications received 71,927 89,461 110,797 124,921 150,747


And what is the ethnic make-up of the children who are subject to these notifications?

Nearly one half of the notifications requiring further action were concerned with Māori children and young people Of the notifications requiring further action between 2008/2009 and 2010/2011: around 46% concerned children and young people identified as Māori 31% concerned children and young people identified as European around 11% concerned children and young people identified as Pacific people.

What type of abuse was found?

 table CY.3: Substantiated findings by type
Type of finding 2006/2007 2007/2008 2008/2009 2009/2010 2010/2011
Number of abuse and neglect findings from investigation of notifications1,2
Emotionally abused 8,256 8,664 10,938 12,535 12,595
Physically abused 2,274 2,321 2,855 2,886 3,225
Sexually abused 1,194 1,003 1,126 1,201 1,505
Neglected 4,486 4,302 4,677 4,403 4,762
Total abuse and neglect findings 16,210 16,290 19,596 21,025 22,087

So how can the picture be summed up? More notifications of which a smaller proportion required further action. However actual substantiations have also increased. So, notwithstanding I haven't accounted for any demographic change, and CYF may be being over-zealous, it looks very much like the overall situation for children is not improving.

No comments: