Thursday, October 22, 2015

How much CYF resource is wasted?

New data shows a significant drop in substantiated findings of child abuse:

 Yet there were 150,905 notifications in 2014/15 - a  3 percent increase on the previous year.

Only 30 percent of notifications require further action.

16,472 substantiated findings from 150,905 notifications (allowing for some year on year overlap) represents 10.9  percent. Note though that multiple findings can apply to one child, just as multiple reports could apply to one child so it would be incorrect to simply state that 10.9 percent of notifications are substantiated. But you get the picture.

Reports are trending up; substantiations are trending down.

The level of notifications that are unnecessary - perhaps even vexatious - must be very high. Or perhaps the difference reflects a gap between CYF's standards and the community's. Certainly the public has been heavily encouraged to report their concerns, and the police are also  now required to make a notification if attending a family violence incident even if the child/ren are not directly involved.

Whatever the reasons for the difference in reports and substance are, it must be costing a fortune in resource.

1 comment:

JC said...

Years ago I remember a Christchurch detective saying that lots of rape complaints made on a weekend were retracted later on a weekday as the parties cooled off.. and I'm certainly aware that accusations of abuse are frequently hurled around at the time of relationship breakups.

I wonder if that explains a fair few of those notifications that go no further.. good old fashioned anger, jealousy and spite augmented by friends of the combatants picking over dozens of historic incidents and looking for sinister interpretations.