Tuesday, June 09, 2020

A pathway but not a panacea


Regarding the ongoing battle between some Maori and Oranga Tamariki:
Hands Off Our Tamariki spokesperson and researcher Alison Green has been comparing the state care systems in Canada and New Zealand.
The Oranga Tamariki legislation restricted mana motuhake, and Māori needed a system of their own like tribes in Canada, Dr Green said.
"We are ready for tribal governments," she said.
"For tribes to be able to enact legislation and for tribes to take over the jurisdiction and authority of their young Māori people and their families and take it right away from the state."
Regarding the Canadian experience:

 When I became a judge in 1976 they were just starting to talk about turning the control of child welfare agencies over to Indigenous groups. This changeover took place during the 1980s, and 90s. The theory advanced by Indigenous advocates was that there were far too many Indigenous children in care because white child care workers did not understand Indigenous culture and the Indigenous way of life. If only Indigenous workers and supervisors could take over, the numbers would go down. That didn’t happen. As the Indigenous agencies took over, the numbers went up instead of down. That remains the case today...
...the state of Indigenous child welfare is no better than it was when Indigenous child welfare agencies took over – by some measures it is a whole lot worse. Those neglected children have become pawns in the political games that are now playing out federally. Parents who have clearly failed their children are let off the hook by advocates claiming that it is not their fault that they drank and made a mess of their children’s lives – it is society’s fault, or it is because of colonialism or residential schools – or almost anything going back five hundred years that might have affected their long dead ancestors’ lives. The irresponsible parents are told that they are victims. Never mind acting like a grownup, getting off welfare and starting to support your family. To the contrary, accepting personal responsibility and changing one’s behaviour is considered an old fashioned and discardable notion. Forget the best interests of the child – permanent victimhood and racial politics are where it’s at. But I will stop.
As I said earlier, I know little about the New Zealand situation. I simply don’t know if there are similarities between Canada’s Indigenous situation and the Maori situation in New Zealand. But if I am allowed to give just one word of advice on the subject of child welfare, it is this: “A child is a child. Keep racial politics out of it, and just see to that child’s best interests.” 

Brian Giesbrecht was a Provincial Court Judge in Manitoba, Canada, from 1976 to 2007. During that time he served as Acting Chief Judge, and Associate Chief Judge. 

It was heartening yesterday to hear OT defending itself on two fronts. 1/  The latest report from the Children's Commissioner represents only 12 mothers - a tiny number of the cases dealt with annually and 2/ it focuses on the mothers and not the best interests of their children.

4 comments:

Jim Rose said...

The report was silent on better protection of children.

Oi said...

I have a 7 year old German Shepherd that loves children.
A few months ago, a family moved next door, a pleasent Thai woman, her Kiwi partner and two teens.
The daughter is about 11, and she and her father were shiacking around outside our property. Dad put his arm around his daughters throat from behind, my dog saw this, launched from where he was lying on our lawn, and started for the father.
I managed to command him to stop and dad let go of the daughter instantly.

The moral of the story?
We need more dogs like this in NZ.... LOL

Jim Rose said...

A friend of mine years ago had a really nervous girlfriend who got a fully trained army guard dog for protection.

When my friend was showing his girlfriend some judo moves, fortunately the dog realised at the last moment they were playing around and it wasn't serious as the dog lunged for my friend in a very menacing way

Brendan McNeill said...

Yes, reverting to tribalism, that should do it.