Sunday, March 03, 2013

More bad stats from Ardern

Jacinda Ardern is clutching at straws.

In the NZ Herald today:

Labour spokeswoman for social development Jacinda Ardern said the highest unemployment numbers were at around 10 per cent in the early 1990s but support for solo parents and invalids have hit record highs during Bennett's reign as Social Development Minister.


Infoshare shows that DPB numbers reached a high of 113,329 in 1998.
In 2011 a new high was reached of 114,039.

However, not all people on the DPB are "solo parents".

The table below shows that at December 2011 100,266 sole parents were on the DPB...

   
Benefit
December 2011
September 2012
December 2012
Quarterly change
Annual change
Domestic Purposes Benefits (DPB)
      114,230
      110,738
      109,118
-1,620
-1.5%
-5,112
-4.5%
     DPB-SP
  100,266
    96,648
    95,138
-1,510
-1.6%
-5,128
-5.1%
     DPB-CSI
7,650
7,806
7,943
137
1.8%
293
3.8%
     DPB-WA
3,859
4,003
3,773
-230
-5.7%
-86
-2.2%
     EMA
2,455
2,281
2,264
-17
-0.7%
-191
-7.8%

  
...compared to 106,881 in 1998 (contained within 2002 report here)



1998

Number
Domestic Purposes Benefit
– Sole Parent
106,881
Domestic Purposes Benefit
– Caring for Sick or Infirm
1,925
Domestic Purposes Benefit
– Woman Alone
2,945
Emergency Maintenance Allowance
1,578
Total
113,329


So every thing else Ardern says in this article in relation to the DPB and sole parents, failure of work-testing etc is bunkum.

Let's look at the invalid's benefit. Using the same Infoshare table, yes, numbers reached a record high in 2011. But under National they increased from 85,197  2008 to 88,134 in 2011 - or 3.4%. Under Labour the increase was 51,173 in 1999 to  79,077 in 2007 or 54.6 percent. 

And as a percentage of the working age population numbers on the Invalid benefit have been trending down since 2009.

Ardern is quite pathetic.

But doesn't the reporter have some responsibility to dig a bit deeper?

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

While you expect politicians and the MSM to get anything right disappointment awaits around every turn.

3:16

Manolo said...

Toothy Ardern is hopeless, utterly hopeless.